This post contains affiliate links. I may receive compensation if you buy something but with no cost to you.

12 Old Fashioned Cocktails Perfect for the Holiday Season

The Old Fashioned isn’t seasonal because it tries to be. It’s seasonal because it adapts. In winter, it absorbs warmth, spice, fruit, and richness without losing its identity. These variations show why one cocktail can carry an entire season.

The Original Old Fashioned

Old Fashioned Filip Puczka from Getty Images
PC Filip Puczka from Getty Images

Before variations, there is the blueprint. Whiskey, sugar, bitters, and citrus. Nothing more, nothing less. The original Old Fashioned remains the standard because it’s balanced, adaptable, and endlessly reliable, especially during the indulgent weeks of winter.

Find the recipe here: https://alushlifemanual.com/how-to-make-an-old-fashioned/

Baked Apple Old Fashioned

Baked Apple Old Fashioned
PC bhofack2 from Getty Images

Apples feel inevitable in December, and this version leans into that logic fully. Warm, softly spiced, and familiar without tipping into sweetness, it works just as well for hosting as it does for a quiet night in.

Find the recipe here: https://alushlifemanual.com/baked-apple-old-fashioned/

Spiced Apple Cider Old Fashioned

Apple Cider Old Fashioned
PC VeselovaElena from Getty Images

This is the Old Fashioned at its most comforting. Reduced cider brings depth rather than sugar, making the drink feel slow and grounding for cold nights when reassurance matters more than precision.

Find the recipe here: https://alushlifemanual.com/spiced-apple-cider-old-fashioned/

Brown Butter Old Fashioned

Brown Butter Old Fashioned
@ Canva Studio

Brown butter adds a savory, almost culinary layer that makes this feel richer than it looks. It’s indulgent without being heavy and turns a classic cocktail into something quietly luxurious.

Find the recipe here: https://alushlifemanual.com/brown-butter-old-fashioned/

Coffee and Brown Sugar Old Fashioned

Coffee Old Fashioned 1
PC @ Shebeko rom depositphotos

This version pushes the Old Fashioned into after-dinner territory. Coffee bitterness and molasses-like sweetness make it ideal for late evenings, when dessert feels optional but a final drink does not.

Find the recipe here: https://alushlifemanual.com/coffee-brown-sugar-old-fashioned/

Salted Honey Old Fashioned

salted honey old fashioned
PC MarianVejcik from Getty Images

Honey softens the drink’s edges, while salt keeps it grounded. The result is rounded, balanced, and subtle, proving that sweetness doesn’t need to shout to be effective.

Find the recipe here: https://alushlifemanual.com/salted-honey-old-fashioned/

Ginger Molasses Old Fashioned

Ginger Molasses Old Fashioned
PC @ EstudioConceito rom depositphotos

Dark, spiced, and unapologetically wintry, this is a colder-weather pour through and through. Ginger adds lift, molasses adds depth, and together they make the Old Fashioned feel built for long nights.

Find the recipe here: https://alushlifemanual.com/how-to-make-the/

Orange Peel Old Fashioned

Classic Old Fashioned
@PC A Lush Life Manual

Citrus in winter is less about freshness and more about aroma. This version leans into the oils and bitterness of orange peel, keeping the drink classic while making it feel seasonally right.

Find the recipe here: https://alushlifemanual.com/orange-peel-old-fashioned/

Vanilla Orange Old Fashioned

Vanilla Orange Old Fashioned
PC @ Fesenko from depositphotos

Vanilla warms everything it touches, softening the brightness of orange into something rounder and calmer. It’s familiar, aromatic, and easy to return to again and again.

Find the recipe here: https://alushlifemanual.com/vanilla-orange-old-fashioned/

Cinnamon Toast Old Fashioned

cinnamon toast old fashioned
PC bhofack2 from Getty Images

Playful without being gimmicky, this variation taps directly into comfort and nostalgia. It shows that the Old Fashioned can have a sense of humor and still feel grown-up.

Find the recipe here: https://alushlifemanual.com/cinnamon-toast-old-fashioned/

Sugar Plum Old Fashioned

plum
PC @ AtlasStudio rom depositphotos

Inspired by the flavors that dominate December itself, this drink feels festive without becoming novelty-driven. It’s elegant, seasonal, and especially fitting in the final days before Christmas.

Find the recipe here: https://alushlifemanual.com/sugar-plum-old-fashioned/

The New Fashioned

New Fashioned
PC @New Riff

This is where tradition gets a gentle nudge forward. The structure remains intact, but the details evolve, showing that even the most classic cocktail still has room to grow.

Find the recipe here: https://alushlifemanual.com/new-fashioned/

Taken together, these drinks aren’t about reinvention. They’re about restraint. Letting the Old Fashioned carry winter flavors naturally is what makes it the one cocktail that stays steady when everything else feels excessive.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.