The Old Fashioned is a cocktail that beautifully captures simplicity and sophistication. Just three ingredients—bourbon, sugar, and bitters—come together to create a drink that has been cherished for generations. But the bourbon you choose can make all the difference, elevating the cocktail from good to truly exceptional. Here are the top 10 bourbons that pair perfectly with this classic libation, ensuring every sip is memorable.
Buffalo Trace
Buffalo Trace offers a harmonious blend of vanilla, toffee, and oak, making it a staple for bourbon lovers. Its medium body and approachable flavor profile make it an ideal base for an Old Fashioned.
When mixed, Buffalo Trace enhances the cocktail’s depth, allowing the bitters and citrus garnish to shine. Its affordability and availability add to its appeal, making it a must-have for any home bar.
Bulleit Bourbon
Bulleit Bourbon is renowned for its high rye content, which adds a distinctive spiciness and depth. With flavors of oak, nutmeg, and caramel, it provides a bold backbone for an Old Fashioned.
The robust flavor of Bulleit ensures that the cocktail remains well-rounded and satisfying. This bourbon is an excellent choice for those who prefer their Old Fashioned with a little extra kick.
Wild Turkey 101
Wild Turkey 101 is a bold and spicy bourbon that holds its own in an Old Fashioned. With flavors of caramel, vanilla, and a touch of pepper, it’s a robust choice for whiskey lovers.
The high proof ensures a strong presence in the cocktail, while its rich flavors blend seamlessly with the sugar and bitters. Wild Turkey 101 is perfect for those who appreciate a no-nonsense, full-flavored bourbon.
Woodford Reserve
Woodford Reserve is a go-to bourbon for Old Fashioned enthusiasts. Known for its well-balanced flavor profile, it features notes of dried fruit, caramel, and a hint of spice. The smooth finish ensures that it complements the bitters and sugar without overpowering them.
This bourbon’s subtle sweetness and complexity shine when muddled with sugar and bitters. Its versatility makes it an excellent choice for both beginners and seasoned bourbon drinkers. Whether you’re enjoying a cozy night at home or entertaining guests, Woodford Reserve is a reliable choice.
Old Forester 86 Proof
Old Forester 86 Proof is a classic bourbon that packs a punch without compromising on flavor. Its robust profile includes hints of brown sugar, cinnamon, and clove, making it a bold choice for an Old Fashioned.
The higher proof ensures that the bourbon’s flavors remain prominent, even with the addition of sugar and bitters. Old Forester 86 Proof is a favorite among bartenders for its reliability and versatility.
Four Roses Small Batch
Four Roses Small Batch combines the best of four proprietary recipes to create a nuanced and balanced bourbon. It’s known for its hints of ripe berries, vanilla, and spice, making it a versatile choice for cocktails.
When used in an Old Fashioned, Four Roses Small Batch offers a harmonious blend of sweetness and spice. It’s perfect for those who appreciate a layered, sophisticated flavor profile in their drinks.
Eagle Rare
Eagle Rare is a premium bourbon that delivers exceptional quality with every bottle. With notes of candied almonds, cocoa, and a hint of orange peel, it’s a standout option for an Old Fashioned.
This bourbon’s smoothness and depth enhance the cocktail without overpowering it. Eagle Rare’s subtle citrus notes work beautifully with the traditional orange garnish, creating a cohesive and delightful drink.
Knob Creek Small Batch
Knob Creek’s full-bodied, rich flavor profile is perfect for those who enjoy a bolder bourbon. With notes of toasted nuts, vanilla, and caramel, it’s a powerhouse in the world of whiskey.
Its higher proof gives the Old Fashioned a hearty punch, while its complexity ensures a balanced and flavorful sip. Knob Creek is ideal for those who like their cocktails on the stronger side.
Maker’s Mark
Maker’s Mark’s distinctive red wax seal and wheated mash bill set it apart. Its soft, smooth, and slightly sweet taste profile—featuring notes of vanilla, honey, and baking spices—makes it a fantastic choice for an Old Fashioned.
This bourbon’s lower rye content results in a less spicy finish, allowing the cocktail’s other ingredients to take center stage. Maker’s Mark delivers a consistently delightful drinking experience, perfect for those who appreciate a milder bourbon.
Elijah Craig Small Batch
Elijah Craig Small Batch is a well-rounded bourbon with notes of toffee, vanilla, and a hint of smokiness. Its medium-bodied flavor profile makes it a versatile choice for cocktails.
In an Old Fashioned, Elijah Craig’s sweetness and subtle smoky undertones create a balanced and inviting drink. It’s an excellent option for those who enjoy a bourbon with a touch of complexity.
These ten bourbons offer a spectrum of flavors and strengths, ensuring something for every beginner’s taste. Start with one, explore its nuances, and soon, you’ll be ready to dive deeper into the diverse and delicious world of bourbon. Cheers!
Now Make A Great Old Fashioned
Now that you have your bourbon bottle in house, time to make some cocktails! Here is my list of both classic bourbon cocktails and a few new ones that work for every season!