Bourbon, mulled wine, and an orange peel studded with fresh cloves. That is the whole cast, and it makes a very good drink for a cold night.

The Fireside Manhattan comes from Maker’s Mark, and it takes the shape of a Manhattan and gives it a winter wardrobe. Two ingredients go into the mixing glass, a coupe comes out, and the smell of cloves arrives before the first sip. The recipe card is just below.
Why a Manhattan suits winter
A Manhattan is built on the pairing of whiskey and a spiced, fortified wine. Sweet vermouth traditionally plays that role, with its notes of dried fruit, orange peel and baking spice. Mulled wine is a cousin in the same family, already steeped with cinnamon, cloves, citrus and star anise.
So when mulled wine steps into the vermouth’s place, the drink still reads as a Manhattan. It is dark, silky and stirred, served up in a coupe. It simply smells like the holidays.
Meet Maker’s Mark 46
The bourbon here is Maker’s Mark 46, the first major expression to follow the original Maker’s Mark, which has been made since 1958. It starts as fully matured Maker’s Mark. Ten seared French oak staves are then added to the barrel for a few more months of aging.
The name comes from the stave profile, known as Stave Profile No. 46. It is bottled at 94 proof, a touch higher than the original, and it is a wheated bourbon, so it tastes softer and rounder than a rye-heavy pour. Expect vanilla, caramel and baking spice, which is exactly what a cup of mulled wine is made of. If a distillery visit is on your list, I wrote up the Maker’s Mark distillery tour in Loretto, Kentucky.
Where the mulled wine comes in
Homemade mulled wine is the star of the show. Because you make it yourself, you decide how much cinnamon, clove and orange it carries, and your kitchen smells wonderful while you do it. Make a pot for the evening and you have your cocktail ingredient and a warm mug for the cook, all in one go.
If you would like to brew a batch, my guide to mulled wine drinks has plenty of ideas for winter entertaining. Let it cool before it goes into the mixing glass, so the stir does the chilling.
The clove-studded garnish
The orange peel is more than decoration. Studded with fresh cloves, it gives you the aroma of a pomander, that old holiday trick, right under your nose as you sip. Express the peel over the glass first, and the citrus oils land on the surface of the drink.
It also looks wonderful. A dark, glossy coupe with a spiked orange twist on the rim is a handsome sight on a holiday table.
When to serve it
Pour one before dinner, after a long walk in the cold, or for the first guest through the door at a winter party. It is made one glass at a time, so it works for a quiet night in as well as for a gathering. Chill the coupe in the freezer while the wine cools and you are set.
More Manhattans and bourbon to sip
If you are in a Manhattan mood, here are some companions from my shelf:
- Start with the Maker’s Mark Manhattan for the classic build.
- Try the Perfect Manhattan, made with both sweet and dry vermouth.
- Go darker with the Black Manhattan.
- Browse more easy bourbon cocktails for your home bar.
- Keep the festive mood going with easy Christmas cocktails.
- Visit the best bars in New York, the Manhattan’s home city.
FAQ
What is a Fireside Manhattan?
It is a winter Manhattan from Maker’s Mark that pairs Maker’s Mark 46 bourbon with homemade mulled wine. It is stirred, served in a coupe and garnished with an orange peel studded with fresh cloves.
What bourbon should I use?
Maker’s Mark 46, a French oaked bourbon bottled at 94 proof. Its vanilla, caramel and baking spice notes suit the spices in mulled wine.
Should the mulled wine be warm?
Let it cool first. The drink is stirred over ice and served up, so a room-temperature or chilled mulled wine gives you the best result.
Is it shaken or stirred?
Stirred, like any Manhattan, which keeps it silky and clear.
Can I make the mulled wine ahead?
Yes. Brew it earlier in the day or the day before, then keep it in the fridge until you are ready to stir.
Why Lush Life loves it
A Manhattan that smells like a Christmas market, made with a bourbon that has a story. It takes two ingredients and a little patience with a pot of wine, and it rewards you with a glass worth lingering over. Cheers!
Here is the recipe

Fireside Manhattan
Equipment
Ingredients
- 50 ml Maker's 46 Bourbon
- 25 ml mulled wine
- Orange peel studded with fresh cloves, to garnish
Instructions
- Add the Maker’s Mark and mulled wine to a mixing glass filled with ice.
- Stir until chilled, then strain into a chilled coupe glass.
- Garnish with orange peel studded with fresh cloves.
